Galvanising criticality: Analysing trans health policy in a hostile political context
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.11157/anzswj-vol36iss4id1211Keywords:
Human rights, Trans Health, Anti-colonialism, transgender, depathologicalisationAbstract
INTRODUCTION: Pathologisation has long provided the architecture for governing access to gender-affirming medical care. An explicit orientation towards human rights in the latest revision of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health’s (WPATH) Standards of Care is an important success in achieving trans depathologisation. This development is the result of sustained efforts by trans activists who have been dismantling pathologising structures and practices in the face of intensifying opposition and vitriolic attacks.
METHODS: We present findings from the comparison of approaches to depathologisation in the WPATH Standards for Care, version 7 (SOC-7), and an alternative best-practices guide created by the Spanish Network for Depathologization of Trans Identities (the Guide) using the What’s the Problem Represented to be? (WPR) approach to policy analysis. This WPR analysis is informed by trans and First Nations policy workers, scholars, and activists. This methodological–conceptual approach is used to explore uncertainties about the limits of a liberal rights model in the Guide.
FINDINGS: Situating rights in the broader field of governing logics indicates that, although this approach seeks to replace harmful practices, it does little to address underlying colonial mechanisms. Noticing uncertainty supported consideration of the dynamic ways that medicalisation and rights, liberalism and neoliberalism, and colonial power are sustained in trans health policy.
CONCLUSION: In an increasingly hostile context, when uncertainty about the transformative capacity of human rights necessarily shifts focus, returning to trans analytics provides solid ground for deepening interrogation of the colonial conditions of care to enable full depathologisation to unfold.
References
Adler-Bolton, B., & Gill-Peterson, J. (2022, November 21). Body Politics w/ Jasbir Puar In Death Panel. https://www.deathpanel.net/transcripts/jasbir-puar-body-politics
American Psychiatric Association. (2000). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders-lV-TR. American Psychiatric Publishing.
American Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (5th ed.). American Psychiatric Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.books.9780890425596
Ansara, Y. G., & Hegarty, P. (2014). Methodologies of misgendering: Recommendations for reducing cisgenderism in psychological research. Feminism & Psychology, 24(2), 259-270. https://doi.org/10.1177/0959353514526217
Arjonilla, E. O. (2014). Reframing Care Practices on Transgender Health: The International Campaign Stop Trans Pathologization. In A. Bammé, G. Getzinger, & T. Berger (Eds.), Yearbook 2014 of the Institute for Advanced Studies on Science, Technology and Society. Profil.
Ashley, F., St. Amand, C. M., & Rider, G. N. (2021). The continuum of informed consent models in transgender health. Family Practice, 1-2. https://doi.org/10.1093/fampra/cmab047
Bacchi, C., & Goodwin, S. (2016). Poststructural Policy Analysis: A Guide to Practice. Palgrave Macmillan US.
Barker, J. (Ed.). (2017). Critically Sovereign: Indigenous Gender, Sexuality, and Feminist Studies. Duke University Press. https://doi.org/10.1515/9780822373162.
Billard, T. J. (2024). The politics of transgender health misinformation. Political Communication, 41(2), 344-352. https://doi.org/10.1080/10584609.2024.2303148
Carlson, B., Day, M., O'Sullivan, S., & Kennedy, T. (2023). The Routledge handbook of Australian Indigenous peoples and futures. Taylor & Francis Group.
Coleman, E., Bockting, W., Botzer, M., Cohen-Kettenis, P., DeCuypere, G., Feldman, J., Fraser, L., Green, J., Knudson, G., & Meyer, W. J. (2012). Standards of Care for the Health of Transsexual, Transgender, and Gender Nonconforming People, 7th Version. The World Professional Association for Transgender Health.
Coleman, E., Radix, A., Bouman, W. P., Brown, G. R., de Vries, A. L. C., Deutsch, M. B., Ettner, R., Fraser, L., Goodman, M., Green, J., Hancock, A. B., Johnson, T. W., Karasic, G. A., Knudson, D. H., Leibowitz, S. F., Meyer-Bahlburg, H. F. L., Monstrey, S. J., Motmans, J., Nahata, L., . . . Arcelus, J. (2022). Standards of Care for the Health of Transgender and Gender Diverse People, Version 8. International Journal of Transgender Health, 23(sup1), S1-S259. https://doi.org/10.1080/26895269.2022.2100644
GATE. (2012). It’s Time for Reform: Trans* Health Issues in the International Classification of Diseases. https://gate.ngo/knowledge-portal/news/its-time-for-reform-trans-health-issues-in-the-icd/
GATE. (2024). Campaigns: Anti-Gender Movements. Global Action for Trans Equality. https://gate.ngo/knowledge-portal/campaign/anti-gender-movements/
Gilmore, R. W., & Lambert, L. (2019). Making Abolition Geography in California’s Central Valley with Ruth Wilson Gilmore. The Funambulist, 21, 14-19.
Gossett, C. (2014). We will not rest in peace: AIDS activism, black radicalism, queer and/or trans resistance. In J. Haritaworn, A. Kuntsman, & S. Posocco (Eds.), Queer Necropolitics (pp. 31-50). Routledge.
Gould, W. A. (2024). Coconstructing (Trans-)Capitalist Realism: Trans Activisms Collude in the Political Economy Structuring Anti-Trans Laws. TSQ: Transgender Studies Quarterly, 11(2), 214-238. https://doi.org/10.1215/23289252-11215470
Hattotuwa, S., Hannah, K., & Taylor, K. (2023). Transgressive transitions: Transphobia, community building, bridging, and bonding within Aotearoa New Zealand’s disinformation ecologies March-April 2023. The Disinformation Project. https://www.thedisinfoproject.org/s/Transgressive-Transitions.pdf
Horton, C., & Pearce, R. (2024). The U.K.’s Cass Review Badly Fails Trans Children. Scientific American. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-u-k-s-cass-review-badly-fails-trans-children/
Howe, R., Harper, A., & Hammoud-Beckett, S. (2019). Uncovering Games of Truth: A Collaborative Exploration of the Ways Transgender and Non-Binary young People Access Health Care and Support. In D. Baines, B. Bennett, S. Goodwin, & M. Rawsthorne (Eds.), Working Across Difference: Social Work, Social Policy and Social Justice (pp. 137-152). Red Globe Press.
Irving, D. (2013). Against the grain: Teaching transgender human rights. Sexualities, 16(3-4), 319-335. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1177/1363460713479746
Jacobsen, K. (2024). Prioritizing Trans Autonomy over Medical Authority in Gender-Affirming Care: The Role of Risk and Uncertainty. Bulletin of Applied Transgender Studies, 3(1-2), 1-19. https://doi.org/10.57814/eay5-ey57
Malatino, H. (2020). Trans Care. University of Minnesota Press.
Meronek, T., & Griffin-Gracy, M. M. (2023). Miss Major Speaks: Conversations with a Black Trans Revolutionary. Verso Books.
Meyer, W., Bockting, W. O., Cohen-Kettenis, P., Coleman, E., Diceglie, D., Devor, H., Gooren, L., Hage, J. J., Kirk, S., Kuiper, B., Laub, D., Lawrence, A., Menard, Y., Patton, J., Schaefer, L., Webb, A., & Wheeler, C. C. (2002). The Harry Benjamin International Gender Dysphoria Association's Standards of Care for Gender Identity Disorders, Sixth Version. Journal of Psychology & Human Sexuality, 13(1), 1-30. https://doi.org/10.1300/J056v13n01_01
O’Sullivan, S. (2021). The Colonial Project of Gender (and Everything Else). Genealogy, 5(3), 67. https://doi.org/10.3390/genealogy5030067
Pehl, E. (2024). On “Deadnaming” the “Vanishing Indian”. TSQ: Transgender Studies Quarterly, 11(1), 80-96. https://doi.org/10.1215/23289252-11131702
Platero, R. L. (2020). Redistribution and recognition in Spanish transgender laws. Politics and Governance, 8(3), 253-265. https://doi.org/10.17645/pag.v8i3.2856
Puar, J. K. (2017). The Right to Maim: Debility, Capacity, Disability. Duke University Press.
Schwend, A. S. (2020). Trans health care from a depathologization and human rights perspective. Public Health Reviews, 41(1), 1-17. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40985-020-0118-y
Sharman, Z. (2016). The Remedy: Queer and Trans Voices on Health and Health Care. Arsenal Pulp Press.
shuster, s. m. (2021). Trans Medicine: The Emergence and Practice of Treating Gender. NYU Press.
Spade, D. (2015). Normal Life: Administrative Violence, Critical Trans Politics, and the Limits of Law (Revised and expanded ed.). Duke University Press.
Stoff, M. (2023). Why gender essentialism is a white supremacist ideology. Overland. https://overland.org.au/2023/03/why-gender-essentialism-is-a-white-supremacist-ideology/
Stone, S. (1991). The Empire Strikes Back: A Posttranssexual Manifesto. In J. Epstein & K. Straub (Eds.), In Body Guards: The Cultural Politics of Gender Ambiguity (pp. 280–304). Routledge.
Stop Trans Pathologization (STP). (2010). Best Practices Guide To Trans Health Care In The National Health System. https://itgl.lu/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/STP_guide_health.pdf
Strauss, P., Cook, A., Winter, S., Watson, V., Toussaint, D. W., & Lin, A. (2017). Trans Pathways: The mental health experiences and care pathways of trans young people. . Telethon Kids Institute. https://www.telethonkids.org.au/projects/past/trans-pathways/
Stryker, S. (2017). Transgender History: The roots of today's revolution (Second ed.). Seal Press.
Stryker, S., & Sullivan, N. (2009). King's Member, Queen's Body: Transsexual Surgery, Self-Demand Amputation and the Somatechnics of Sovereign Power. In S. Murray & N. Sullivan (Eds.), Somatechnics: Queering the Technolisation of Bodies (pp. 49-64). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315609867
TGEU. (2024, May 15). Trans Rights Index & Map 2024 reveals polarisation in trans rights in Europe and Central Asia. TGEU (Trans Europe and Central Asia) https://tgeu.org/tgeus-trans-rights-index-map-2024-reveals-polarisation-in-trans-rights-in-europe-and-central-asia/
Winters, K. (2022). Contradictions and Compromises of Principle in the SOC8. Trans Policy Reform Blog. https://transpolicyreform.files.wordpress.com/2023/02/202210soc8principlesj.1.pdf
World Health Organization. (2016). International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems (10th ed.). https://icd.who.int/browse10/2016/en
World Health Organization. (2019). International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems, 11th Revision. Geneva: World Health Organization
Worley, J. (2011). ‘Street Power’ and the Claiming of Public Space: San Francisco’s ‘Vanguard’ and Pre-Stonewall Queer Radicalism. In N. Smith & E. A. Stanley (Eds.), Captive Genders: Trans Embodiment and the Prison Industrial Complex (2nd ed., pp. 41-56). AK Press.
Yogyakarta Principles. (2017). Yogyakarta Principles Plus 10: Principles on the Application of International Human Rights Law in Relation to Sexual Orientation, Gender Identity, Gender Expression and Sex Characteristics to Complement the Yogyakarta Principles. http://www.yogyakartaprinciples.org/principles-en/yp10/
Zoe Belle Gender Collective. (2021). Transgender and Gender Diverse Inclusive-Care Guide for Hospital Based Healthcare Professionals. Zoe Belle Gender Collective with Melbourne Health. https://zbgc.org.au/resources/zbgc-resources/zbgc-best-practice-for-tgd-healthcare/
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Aotearoa New Zealand Association of Social Workers
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
By completing the online submission process, you confirm you accept this agreement. The following is the entire agreement between you and the Aotearoa New Zealand Association of Social Workers (ANZASW) and it may be modified only in writing.
You and any co-authors
If you are completing this agreement on behalf of co-authors, you confirm that you are acting on their behalf with their knowledge.
First publication
By submitting the work you are:
- granting the ANZASW the right of first publication of this work;
- confirming that the work is original; and
- confirming that the work has not been published in any other form.
Once published, you are free to use the final, accepted version in any way, as outlined below under Copyright.
Copyright
You assign copyright in the final, accepted version of your article to the ANZASW. You and any co-authors of the article retain the right to be identified as authors of the work.
The ANZASW will publish the final, accepted manuscript under a Creative Commons Attribution licence (CC BY 4.0). This licence allows anyone – including you – to share, copy, distribute, transmit, adapt and make commercial use of the work without needing additional permission, provided appropriate attribution is made to the original author or source.
A human-readable summary of the licence is available from http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0, which includes a link to the full licence text.
Under this licence you can use the final, published version of the article freely – such as depositing a copy in your institutional research repository, uploading a copy to your profile on an academic networking site or including it in a different publication, such as a collection of articles on a topic or in conference proceedings – provided that original publication in Aotearoa New Zealand Social Work is acknowledged.
This agreement has no effect on any pre-publication versions or elements, which remain entirely yours, and to which we claim no right.
Reviewers hold copyright in their own comments and should not be further copied in any way without their permission.
The copyright of others
If your article includes the copyright material of others (e.g. graphs, diagrams etc.), you confirm that your use either:
- falls within the limits of fair dealing for the purposes of criticism and review or fair use; OR
- that you have gained permission from the rights holder for publication in an open access journal.
